www.scantips.com

Comparisons of Optical Slave Triggers for Speedlights

(With attention to the Nikon SB-600, indirectly)

Triggering Manual flash mode requires either sync cords, radio triggers, or optical slave triggers on each light.

PC sync cord - A wire cable from camera to the remote flash, to carry the trigger signal from camera shutter. A camera without a PC sync connector can add one with a hot shoe adapter, like the Nikon AS-15. A flash without PC sync connector can add one with a foot mounted accessory. There have been several other styles of sync connectors (than PC), for example, studio lights typically use either a 3.5 mm, or a larger 1/4 inch phono plug at their end of the cable (PC sync connector is at camera end). Additional flashes can be triggered by optical slaves. This trailing cord to a near light is normally little issue when the camera is on a tripod. Variations can exist, but a PC Male to PC Female cable is an extension cord for the normal PC Male to PC Male sync cable. (PC is Prontor-Compur, brand names of German shutters. The PC sync connector dates from the early 1950s).

Radio trigger - a small transmitter on the camera hot shoe relays the trigger signal via radio to a battery powered radio receiver on the remote flash. Perhaps a receiver on every remote flash, but others can be triggered by optical slaves too. This radio signal may go through walls, around corners, often over great range (~100 meters), and is unaffected by sunlight.

Optical slave trigger - A light sensitive sensor at each remote flash, which triggers the flash in sync when it sees the flash of another manual flash unit. This light path can be reflected from close walls or the photo background, but light is line of sight, normally blocked by obstacles. Slaves have the advantage of being triggered by the full working value of the final flash power, but bright sun can interfere with them, obstacles can block them, and another photographer's flash can trigger your lights. Relatively short range, but is a very popular choice in the studio, where few issues exist.

Methods can be combined, trigger one flash by sync cord or radio, and use optical triggers on the other flashes. However these manual methods are incompatible with the Nikon Commander system.

Studio flashes typically have optical slave triggers built in, which work well in that studio setting. Radio triggers are popular to add, but for an indoor studio situation, optical slaves may be simpler. This article is about optical slave triggers, such as are found on Ebay. Trigger the one nearest manual mode flash any way you can (sync cord or radio), and its flash triggers the other optical triggers in sync (if in range).

The Nikon SB-700, SB-800, SB-900 and SB-910 speedlights have exceptionally fine optical slave triggers built in, selected in SU-4 mode. The Nikon SB-26, SB-50DX, and SB-80DX flashes also have slave triggers built in. However most speedlight flashes do not, and the SB-600 does not. Such slave accessories can be added to the flash foot or PC terminal, but unfortunately, the SB-600 has a low sync voltage, which can make some optical slaves be problematic. Because, these optical triggers have no batteries - they are instead powered by the flash sync voltage. This sync voltage is present on the speedlight shoe foot (center pin), and on any sync connector that may be present.

The issue prompting this discussion is that the SB-600 has a low sync voltage. My Fluke 75 III DVM (0.3%) reads sync voltage of my two SB-800's as 3.63 volts, which is more than a volt lower than older models. A friend says his SB-600/SB-800/SB-900 models all measure the same sync voltage (same as each other, but his meter said 2V?) But it is easy to believe they have the same circuitry inside them. So if the SB-600 and SB-800 have the same sync voltage, and this voltage powers the optical slaves, then the premise here is that the SB-800 data below should be applicable to the SB-600 too. Not all optical slave triggers will work with low sync voltage... for example, the Wein Peanut slave below needs 5 volts to work at all, but then it works very well. Most slaves work better with the higher voltage.

Sync voltage is the voltage placed on the sync cable and hot shoe foot by the flash unit. The camera shutter simply shorts this sync voltage as the signal to trigger the manual flash in sync. This same sync voltage also powers the external optical slave triggers - and the issue is that lower voltage may affect their lower trigger sensitivity. The slave sensor also shorts this sync voltage when it senses a flash, to trigger the unit in sync. Today, sync voltage is nominally around 5 volts, except these newest Nikon SB models are lower, about 3.6 volts., and this affects the external optical slaves that are powered by sync voltage.

Some old flashes might exceed 200 volts sync - which could harm some digital cameras. Nikon DSLR are rated to 250 volts - see camera manual section about Optional Flashes, paragraph about "Use only Nikon Flash Accessories". You can easily measure the sync voltage with the flash turned on, while not connected to anything. Measure DC voltage from large center pin on speedlight foot, to the metal foot (or to the metal slide contacts on each side of a plastic foot).

Here is a good article about measuring the sync voltage on your speedlight. A $10 voltmeter may read a couple of volts off, but the safety issue is only the big ballpark that is important - is it less than 10 or 20 volts, or is it more than that? For a reference to check the voltmeter: a fresh new dry cell battery should measure about 1.5 volts (carbon-zinc 1.55V or alkaline maybe almost 1.6V). Note that an easy slip of the meter probe while measuring, likely can short center pin to flash shoe, which probably will flash it accidentally. No harm to the flash, but expect that to happen, and guard your eyes - set it to low power and aimed away, but NOT face down on anything that can be scorched by the hot flash tube.

There are "digital" optical slave triggers, designed for use with TTL, which ignore the first digital preflash (provided because some compact cameras cannot set manual flash mode), and then trigger in sync with the subsequent final flash (but which still cannot work with the more complex Nikon Commander). Most of these have batteries in them, for the timing circuits. Some have a switch to select "film" mode, to trigger from the first flash, to be usable for Manual mode. Untested, but it is conceivable that the battery allows some of these to work better, regardless of sync voltage.

So, the major point here is that I am assuming my SB-800 tests are also valid for a SB-600, with same trigger voltage of same current group from same manufacturer, should work the same with the same slave trigger. Obviously, the point here is not about use with the SB-800, as the SB-800 already includes what it needs. The SB-800 (and SB-700, SB-900 and SB-910) include a self-powered built-in optical slave (called SU-4 mode), but the SB-600 does not include it.

So, the major point here is that I am assuming my SB-800 tests are also valid for a SB-600, with same trigger voltage of same current group from same manufacturer, should work the same with the same slave trigger. Obviously, the point here is not about use with the SB-800, as the SB-800 already includes what it needs. The SB-800 (and SB-700, SB-900 and SB-910) include a self-powered built-in optical slave (called SU-4 mode), but the SB-600 does not include it.

The Ebay slaves below are generally in the $7 to $12 range. These slave tests are triggered from a Nikon D300 internal flash in Manual flash mode at 1/128 power, and again at its Full power. The D300 internal flash is small (guide number 43, feet, ISO 100), and is no more than 1/4 power of a SB-600. If you are triggering with a speedlight at 1/4 power, then that will be similar to the D300 full power result below. A stronger trigger flash would see additional range (some of the specs say greater range, triggering with a flash larger than this internal flash). Actual use probably involves a wall or background reflection, but maybe not great distance.

These tests are best case, aiming the optical slave sensor directly at the triggering flash, line of sight, with the camera lens and flash aimed back at the slave sensor. The chart shows the maximum distance range at which they would trigger (at this trigger power level). The slave either triggered, or it did not (witnessed by a picture of the slave flashing).

For reference: With the same triggering D300 flash at 1/128 power:

An Alienbees B400 internal slave will trigger at 43 feet (better than any of these).

An SB-800 in SU-4 internal slave Manual mode will trigger at 132 feet.

Optical Slave Trigger

(In no particular order)

Nikon SB-800 flash
3.63 volts sync
Nikon SB-24 flash
4.93 volts sync
Internet Link Sources

(unsure how permanent?)

Triggered by 1/128 power Triggered by Full power Triggered by 1/128 power Triggered by Full power
1. Sonia High Range Slave
with rotating hot shoe
24 feet40 feet 24 feet41 feet Rotating Hot Shoe Flash Slave Optical Sensor
2. Sonia Slave With Multi-terminal Hot Shoe (Orange)

This one is my choice

21 feet45 feet 23.5 feet48.5 feet Sonia Remote Flash Slave Unit With Hot Shoe High Range   The one received had an orange base.
3. Sonia Syncro Eye Slave
High Range
(Orange)
15 feet30 feet 18 feet32.5 feet High Range Peanut Flash Slave Optical Sensor NEW 60'   The one received had an orange base.
4. Sonia Optical Slave Sensor, Extended Range
(Orange)
7 feet22 feet 9 feet27 feet Extended Range Optical Slave Sensor with Male PC Connector'
5. Sonia Syncro Eye Slave (for Canon)
(Green)
8.5 feet22 feet 11 feet26 feet High Range Peanut Flash Slave Optical Sensor
6. Wein Peanut Slave
WEPN
won't workwon't work 29 feet 90 feet Wein WEPN Peanut Slave (100' Range)
7. Seagull SYK-3 Optical Slave Trigger 10 feet24 feet 23 feet41 feet SYK-3 Optical Slave Trigger for Hot Shoe Flash

These are the triggers used. I see no difference in appearance of the three orange ones. Of these, #2 was the most sensitive, and it came with the all-metal hot shoe adapter in a small cardboard box, marked Sonia Multiterminal Slave Unit (box did not mention High Range). #3 came foam packed in a plastic box in a cardboard sleeve that said Sonia High Range. The weaker #4 with male PC was bulk packed in a small plastic bag, with no name. No markings on them, but some wide performance variation certainly appears to exist on the orange units.

Sonia is a brand name from India.

Optical slaves are normally triggered by one of the working lights, using its full working power. I know using the little D300 flash is a confusion factor, but the low power was to allow comparing the sensitivity in the house. I had a 52 foot span in the house, where I could lay down a measuring tape. But to check the SB-800 internal SU-4 slave triggered by D300 internal flash at 1/128 power level, I had to open front door and cross the street. At 132 feet (shown), my back was at a fence, no more space. Direct line of sight, both the triggering flash and the remote slave sensor were facing either other. The SB-800 internal slave can use the internal battery power, so it is not dependent on the sync voltage. I did not attempt to check it triggered with full power.
With the Wein Peanut triggered with full power of the internal flash, the SB-24 was triggering from the side walk. Both are pretty good stuff, both simply just work, seemingly with any reflection indoors.

AWL Commander comparison: The D300 internal flash Commander triggered the Remote mode SB-800 (manual power level) at 120 feet in this same setting (more reliable a couple of feet less), which I think may be about double the range of the SU-800. The D300 commander with added SG-3IR infrared shield triggered at 77 feet, and a SB-800 commander triggered at 88 feet (24mm zoom - much more if zoomed long). The Commander can do iTTL of course, and optical slaves are only Manual mode, but one expected advantage of the optical slave is that they are triggered by the greater power level of the final flash, where Commander is a minimum power level signal... and is a more complex signal which must be decoded accurately... The range seems pretty good, but it is line of sight, and Commander reliability can vary more in difficult situations.


The #6 Wein Peanut is the most sensitive on the SB-24 (of these triggers here), but it is useless on the low sync voltage of the SB-800. This Double PC Male Ended Adapter is very convenient to connect it and the other slaves with female PC to a flash or foot adapter with female PC connector. Or, the slave could be connected with a short or long PC Male to PC Male cord, to position the slave in the clear, or to move it to a closer range.

#7 Seagull SYK-3 is very plentiful on Ebay. Only issue is that it works better on the SB-24 than on the SB-800. It has a plastic foot, and a metal 1/4 inch thread on the bottom. It takes a couple of weeks to receive items from Hong Kong, but my experiences have been good.

But #6 and #7 seem most affected by the lower sync voltage.

The #1 Rotating Shoe Trigger had good performance, even at the lower sync voltage. It needs no additional mount or PC sync adapter, but this rotating axis seems a weak point mechanically. It seems strong enough with the flash standing upright above it, but horizontal is a worry. It sags - and does seem to stay together, but it does not inspire my confidence. Since most flash heads rotate anyway, I would have preferred a stronger fixed shoe. Some strong expoy glue comes to mind (untried).

It has PC connectors on each side, which can trigger other external flashes from the slave, but the side connectors cannot trigger anything internal inbound from a external source. So it could be used as shown at right, with a flash foot PC adapter (the Sonia adapter shown and used is this one: Synchro Sync Hot Shoe Flash Adapter w Tripod Socket NEW), with the short PC Male to PC Male cord, allowing the flash to be mounted perhaps more securely. This works fine, but I did not solve that part about fastening the slave sensor. It has to be aimed of course, but tape or wire surely does it easily.

The metal shoe on this type does short the other three pins on the Nikon flash foot, but which causes no ill effect... The trigger and the flash both work, and work rather well. The shoes have no hole for the Nikon SB-600 pin lock, but that pin is spring loaded, so you can simply drop the pin anyway, and it holds tight - you cannot remove it without lifting the pin. The optical trigger base has a plastic foot, and also a metal 1/4 inch threaded hole to attach to a mount. The extra PC adapter shown has a metal foot and threaded hole.


The three orange ones (#2, #3, #4) all appear the same, indistinguishable, no unique features or marking. However each had widely different sensitivity performance. #4 has a PC Male connector.

The green one #5 is said to work on Canon EX flashes, where the others probably don't. I don't have Canon gear, and am repeating stuff I cannot verify, but the green Sonia slaves are said to be "Canon compatible". Most slaves won't work on Canon speedlights, because Canon's sync voltage does not drop far enough to release the slave. It fires one time, and then locks up. The green Sonia are said to have special circuitry to work with Canon too. Nikon flashes are no issue in this regard, but SB-600 has a lower sync voltage, which sometimes can be an issue.

#2 is $12, and it would be my choice. It includes the multi-terminal PC adapter and shoe to hold the flash, which has two PC female and one PC Male connections, all of which are triggered by the slave in the one PC Male port. This is NOT a universal PC adapter, because the side ports are outgoing only - the slave (or a PC sync cord) must be only on the PC male connector (but it could be used with a PC Male to PC Female extension cord at the front connector). The unique Male PC connector is important though, to allow Slaves with female connectors to connect directly. This #2 adapter has a sturdy all metal body with a shoe foot, and a 1/4 inch threaded hole to attach it to a mount. But it is unknown how much slave performance variation to expect, from unit to unit - very puzzling. I was hoping #4 with the PC Male connector would work out better, since it has the PC Male connection, and can plug directly into PC Female on adapter or flash.


I additionally tested the third one (#3 High Range Sonia - mid-range of these in sensitivity) in a more real situation. I did not set up the real lights and background, but instead, I simply aimed the SB-800 slave flash at a beige wall 7 feet away, to simulate a background light on a background. The slave flash was blocked with a 30x20 inch foam board (detrimental, intentionally counterproductive, hardest possible way, not helpful), simulating the subject blocking a background light behind them (the post does that pretty well too). The slave cell was aimed at the reflection from the "background", in front of the slave flash. The camera was 12 feet behind the slave, and about 5 feet to the side. That reflected path is 19 feet to the background, and 7 feet back to slave. The D300 internal flash at 1/16 power would trigger it here. This internal flash 1/16 power would compare to a speedlight trigger at no more than 1/64 power (SB-800 50mm zoom triggered it there at 1/128 power).

But a picture of a subject uses more than minimum power, and the subject in right picture (the post) at f/5.6 is with a hot shoe SB-800 at 1/4 power, about 5 stops more power than its minimum 1/128 (and about 7 stops more than internal flash minimum 1/128).

Point of the story: 1/4 power or more from a triggering speedlight is a very realistic actual case (1/4 speedlight power compares to full power from the internal flash). The tiny 1/128 power internal flash is very convenient for comparing, but 1/128 power is an unrealistic limitation for any real situation. Please do not misunderstand the numbers. The point is not that this is difficult to make work. The point is that this is easy to make work. It is only the description that is awkward.

The light path to the slave often needs the wall reflection, and perhaps its range is marginal for extreme cases, but the point is, this is very adequate slave performance for most cases. The optical slave does have the advantage of being triggered from the full final flash power level. My actual studio is normally sideways where the camera is, but I have to move some stuff there. The measuring tape on the floor is some of the technical facilities of my slave testing lab. :)


The three orange units had rather different performance levels however. I don't understand that. I do notice that those internal photocells are mounted at slightly different positions and angles, probably not good, but I have no clue if that is a factor, or how to predict it. These range measurements can be slightly variable, but I think within a couple of inches. Remember, these are Ebay's cheapest.


Menu of the other Photo and Flash pages here

Copyright © 2010-2016 by Wayne Fulton - All rights are reserved.

Previous Menu